Monster of the Week

Monster of the Week

Salt or Ketchup?

playful horror poem

Jessica Maison's avatar
Jessica Maison
Mar 24, 2025
∙ Paid

Salt or ketchup is usually a pretty straightforward question.

Both, right?

Not if you are forced on the regular, like I am, to play a macabre game of Would You Rather. Please enjoy this writing warm-up in the guise of a poem.

I am working on the siren-inspired horror short. I’m at about 1000 words and am still not entirely happy with it. Never fear, I will be happy with it eventually, and it will materialize in your inbox soon.

a group of bottles on a counter
Photo by Diane Picchiottino on Unsplash

Salt or Ketchup?

“Would you rather…”

she muses, eyes twinkling,

gripping her bloody canine that just fell out.

Flashing me a gapped grin,

her tongue slips into the new vacancy.

Groaning, I shake my head in protest.

A mischievous lift of an eyebrow

follows a thrust of her tooth toward me

and her favorite refrain,

“Would you rather…

eat ground up teeth as salt…

OR

ketchup made of human blood?"

“Neither.”

She cackles.

“You have to pick one.”

“Do I? I didn’t sign a contract.”

“That’s the game.”

I sigh, resistance futile.

“Once or forever?”

“For. Th…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Jessica Judd · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture